Oh, my GOD. This is an unaired ep of the show. I firmly believe that all of it happened. *g*

I love the structure of the Jeremy-letter, with all his little comments, and Dan still being the craziest guy in the room, and oh! oh! this bit:

I'm not sure what Dana was more embarrassed by--asking Dan and Casey to make out in front of everyone, or challenging Sally to a duel.

"A duel?" Sam asked. "Seriously?"

"Put 'em in bikinis and a vat of hot oil and I'd pay a dollar to watch it."

"Dean."

"Man's got a point," Dan said.

So perfect. I <3 this a million.